Suki, I am honoured that you would ask me to comment on workbook lesson 14, which I think you can read here. In the answer that follows, I use the word God because the Course uses it. For me, it is nothing more than a label of convenience that is part of one set of metaphors…no better or worse in my mind than any other set of metaphors used to describe our world. I hope you will substitute whichever word works best from your metaphor set.
Model #1: Get some perspective.
Step outside your body (use your imagination for a minute). Step outside your body and float up above the room. Float above the city. Keep going out… out… out. It may help to watch the Eames’ film “Powers of Ten” before doing this exercise.
Get out there in the solar system and keep going. Go out of our galaxy. Go all the way to the next galaxy and beyond. Get some perspective. Now look at the whole thing…all the spinning systems and planets and comets and stars, and tell me. Is there a plane crash?
When you walk to the store, you step on many little creatures and kill them. You are somebody’s earthquake. Is there really an earthquake, or is it just a matter of perspective? To the inchworm on the sidewalk, something catastrophic happened. But is the “catastrophe” real or created by that inchworm’s perspective? What about God’s perspective? Do you mourn each skin cell that sloughs off, soon to be replaced by a fresh one?
When you say “plane crash,” you’re talking about two things – an event or situation plus your thoughts, interpretation, value judgements of same. What you really think is that a plane crash is a terrible thing. It’s a disaster. It’s something to feel depressed about, or fearful about or confused about. Your view of it helps you to see the world as chaotic, meaningless. Why would God let it happen? But I am telling you, God did not make a disaster nor anything meaningless. You are making it with your thoughts.
Before you added your judgments and thoughts to the picture, there was no catastrophe. There is just the Universe chugging along doing what a good universe does. Birth happens. Death happens. Leaves fall off trees. Is that a catastrophe? It may feel like one to that particular leaf; I don’t know. I don’t think God created a catastrophe when God designed leaves to fall off trees in the autumn. It’s not even really death; it’s the death of one physical form. The human ego provides the definition of “crash” and “war” and “illness.”
In order for you to see physical death or decline as a bad thing, you have to view yourself as separate from the whole, as somehow deserving to be exempt from the natural processes of life and death.
Think about a virus that causes a bad flu in your grandmother. Is this illness? It is in the thoughts of the grandmother and her family. But what is it to the virus germs? To them, it is just transportation. Do they not deserve to live, too? Did God not create them to thrive just as She created us to thrive? There is a balance in the design. Sometimes your grandmother gets to live another day, sometimes it’s the virus’ turn to live another day. There is nothing good or bad but thinking makes it so.
Is there war? Is there illness? Is there a plane crash?
Model #2: you are responsible for your hologram
Nobody exists in your hologram except you. The others who appear to exist are creations of your mind projected onto the screen of your hologram.
You will ask, “But what about my son, my ex, my friend? Are they not real?”
I say to you that they are each real within their own dreams, but not in yours. In your dream, they are characters you have created and put there.
Now, back to whether that war, that plane crash or that disease is real.
Is anyone shooting at you right now? No. Then how does that war exist for you? You are creating it out of images from the television or newspaper. God is not creating that, you are. The paper is real because you are touching it. You can even put it to your nose and smell it. But there is no war in the room with you right now. It doesn’t exist.
Ah, but what about a so-called illness that you are currently experiencing? Again, there are things that are real and there is the spin put onto it by your mind. If you stay in the present moment at every moment, there is no diagnosis. There is only what is happening in each moment as it unfolds. Your mind can make anything of it that it wants to. If you open to the Voice of the Holy Spirit, you can experience what is really happening, which just is what it is. If you listen to ego, you will hear a story that is full of fear and loss and I don’t know what all. Which one is reality?
Model #3 – There is a third model that I don’t feel very qualified to expound on and am not even sure what to name it. I might not even understand the gist of it, but I’ll do my best to describe how I THINK it goes: We are dreaming this world into existence together. We are creating war and famine. When we stop dreaming them into existence, they will stop. God does not necessarily want us to create these things with our minds, but won’t stop us because we have free will. One by one, She is calling us back out of this illusion, back to Truth, back to peace and love and harmony.
Think about what Gandhi said. Be the change you wish to see in the world. You cannot make everyone on this planet stop dreaming the war. You can only take responsibility for your dream. So withdraw your belief from it and you are doing your part to shut it down. Although this model sounds impossible and mind-blowing, I can tell you from experience that acting as if this is true causes it to begin to be true.
Under which model this example goes, I’m not sure, but I can share an experience with you. When I stop believing in crime, I begin to live in a world without any.
The other day I reached my car at 3:15 to find dog excrement smeared across my windshield, a crumpled napkin still stuck to it. I did not get upset. I just removed as much as I could using that napkin, put that soiled napkin inside a plastic bag in my trunk so I could throw it away when I got home ( rather than tossing it to the ground, which is what my ego told me to do).
When I got home I spent 30 minutes slowly soaking and cleaning the crusted-on feces from my windshield. I did not label this in my mind with any of the words society would like me to use for it. It was just a situation. In the present moment, there was only one thing to do: clean it off. In my world, there is no such thing as “vandalism” or “insult” or anything like that because I choose to create my hologram without those things. I was with God while I cleaned the windshield. The love was very real. Had that happened to me before I started the Course in Miracles, there would have been a disaster, a reason to have a bad day, a thing called the crime of vandalism and other things. But would they really have existed outside my mind? Today my thoughts have changed and my world does not include crime.